We're writing a new wine list and I'm tasting every day. Wine reps and distributors are bringing wines and I'm furiously taking notes and asking opinions of my colleagues and well.... I guess... passing judgement.
It's a funny situation when I think about it as wines promoted to the high end of the market are likely to have been made carefully and with not a little love. And so none of these producers would have set out to make an 'average' wine. And yet some wines sing and others don't despite the care and attention lavished on all.
But wine notes in these situations tend to be blunt, less given to lists of fruit and flowers and more concerned with stating the personality of the wine and its aptitude to line up.
William Thomas Marlborough Chardonnay 2005
16 months old French oak. Winemaker - Will Hoare, assistant at La Strada. Quite sweet citrus nose. Orange peel, floral, savoury cashew. Grainy palate. Mendoza clone. Refreshing, persistent, clean finish. Pretty yet refined.
Domaine Jaquairy Pinot Noir Central Otago 2003
11 months French oak. Clear garnet red (not over extracted!). Forest floor and white truffle. Spicy, feminine style
Lindis River Pinot Noir Central Otago 2005
Beguiling nose. Red fruits and high acidity. Refreshing. Red liquorice. Quite linear.
Lindis River Pinot Noir Central Otago 2006
Warmer smelling than the 2005. Fruits tending darker and better mouthfeel. Spicy and rich but oak still prominent. Needs time to integrate. Coffee background.
Showing posts with label Valli Banockburn Pinot Noir 2003. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Valli Banockburn Pinot Noir 2003. Show all posts
Wednesday, June 25, 2008
Tuesday, February 19, 2008
What they were drinking
The only reason for grouping these wines together is that they constitue the wines I sold the other night.
I was pleased to sell the Clos Marguerite Sauvignon Blanc 2007, finally, to an English lady who was unsure about drinking Nu Zillund Sav as she normally drank French Sancerre. Apparently the last time she tried Cloudy Bay Sauvignon it got relegated to the cooking wine cupboard and recommending something was further complicated by her request for something "very dry and clean". Given that many of the Sauvignons on our list are the new New Zealand style including partial or full oak (which I quite enjoy) it was becoming difficult to see a way to satisfy her desires. Also, I had never actually tried the Clos Marguerite and was basing my suggestion on half remebered back labels and newspaper tasting notes. Luckily this wine was bang on.
Lemons and subtle tropical fruit on the nose with a background of lovely clean minerality. On the palate this is freshly green, racy and clean. Really tasting the stones of the Awatere along with capsicum. Snappy yet delicate and definitely not shouty.
The next wine was another client ordering conundrum. After telling me that he liked "fruity, weighty" styles of Pinot and my suggesting Central Otago as a suitable region and more specifically some of the fruity and weighty styles therein he threw a curve ball and insisted on the Valli Banockburn Pinot Noir 2003, not, in my estimation, a good choice for his tastes.... Not surprisingly he did not finish the bottle. I'm almost certain he was disappointed. But what can I do if people won't take a little advice?
The nose gives up Autumn plums and thyme and is fragrantly herbaceous with a smoky bacon aspect in the background. However, the palate is pleasant but not distinguished (I prefer the 'Gibbston' fruit Valli) and at 5 years old the fruit is falling away to a dilute tasting finish.
The other Pinot I sold was more successful. The Nuedorf 'Tom's Block' Pinot Noir 2006 is a wine I sell with confidence knowing that it brings the drums at a fraction of the price that most of our guests are prepared to pay. Sometimes it's nice to give rich people a bargain (even if they don't need one).
Red and bramble-berries and mocha chocolate nose preceed an aromatic damson plum and fig-sweet palate. The aromatics play with teasing hints of chocolate to make this a really rewarding mouthful. The palate is quite forward and the length only medium but not really a problem as the wine is so attractive. Flirtatious with summer berries and cinnamon spice that stay refreshing due to a lush green note that is unlike the dried herbs apparent in Central Otago Pinot Noir and more like the blackcurrant leaf of Sauvignon Blanc.
Lastly, there was a request for a 'dry' white wine. A request made so often and yet so confusing as very little on the white wine list has more than 3 grams residual sugar. A request made for so many reasons and mostly nothing to do with lack of sugar in a wine. It seems to mean, "a wine I will like" and this obviously varies wildly and is not predicated on things the sommelier can know. Thankfully the English gentleman in question qualified his wishes to include Chenin Blanc rather than the Chardonnay. And in doing so gave me a direction that brought him the Esk Valley Chenin Blanc 2006.
Apples. Soft red apples in a lovely 'dry' and weighty mouthfeel. A waxy palate with great acid to support the fullness. Fat yet fresh. A hip-hop star of a wine.
And funnily enough at 4.6 grams per litre residual sugar a sweeter wine than he was drinking initially but without the full malolactic of the Te Awa Chardonnay 2005. Funny. No?
I was pleased to sell the Clos Marguerite Sauvignon Blanc 2007, finally, to an English lady who was unsure about drinking Nu Zillund Sav as she normally drank French Sancerre. Apparently the last time she tried Cloudy Bay Sauvignon it got relegated to the cooking wine cupboard and recommending something was further complicated by her request for something "very dry and clean". Given that many of the Sauvignons on our list are the new New Zealand style including partial or full oak (which I quite enjoy) it was becoming difficult to see a way to satisfy her desires. Also, I had never actually tried the Clos Marguerite and was basing my suggestion on half remebered back labels and newspaper tasting notes. Luckily this wine was bang on.
Lemons and subtle tropical fruit on the nose with a background of lovely clean minerality. On the palate this is freshly green, racy and clean. Really tasting the stones of the Awatere along with capsicum. Snappy yet delicate and definitely not shouty.
The next wine was another client ordering conundrum. After telling me that he liked "fruity, weighty" styles of Pinot and my suggesting Central Otago as a suitable region and more specifically some of the fruity and weighty styles therein he threw a curve ball and insisted on the Valli Banockburn Pinot Noir 2003, not, in my estimation, a good choice for his tastes.... Not surprisingly he did not finish the bottle. I'm almost certain he was disappointed. But what can I do if people won't take a little advice?
The nose gives up Autumn plums and thyme and is fragrantly herbaceous with a smoky bacon aspect in the background. However, the palate is pleasant but not distinguished (I prefer the 'Gibbston' fruit Valli) and at 5 years old the fruit is falling away to a dilute tasting finish.
The other Pinot I sold was more successful. The Nuedorf 'Tom's Block' Pinot Noir 2006 is a wine I sell with confidence knowing that it brings the drums at a fraction of the price that most of our guests are prepared to pay. Sometimes it's nice to give rich people a bargain (even if they don't need one).
Red and bramble-berries and mocha chocolate nose preceed an aromatic damson plum and fig-sweet palate. The aromatics play with teasing hints of chocolate to make this a really rewarding mouthful. The palate is quite forward and the length only medium but not really a problem as the wine is so attractive. Flirtatious with summer berries and cinnamon spice that stay refreshing due to a lush green note that is unlike the dried herbs apparent in Central Otago Pinot Noir and more like the blackcurrant leaf of Sauvignon Blanc.
Lastly, there was a request for a 'dry' white wine. A request made so often and yet so confusing as very little on the white wine list has more than 3 grams residual sugar. A request made for so many reasons and mostly nothing to do with lack of sugar in a wine. It seems to mean, "a wine I will like" and this obviously varies wildly and is not predicated on things the sommelier can know. Thankfully the English gentleman in question qualified his wishes to include Chenin Blanc rather than the Chardonnay. And in doing so gave me a direction that brought him the Esk Valley Chenin Blanc 2006.
Apples. Soft red apples in a lovely 'dry' and weighty mouthfeel. A waxy palate with great acid to support the fullness. Fat yet fresh. A hip-hop star of a wine.
And funnily enough at 4.6 grams per litre residual sugar a sweeter wine than he was drinking initially but without the full malolactic of the Te Awa Chardonnay 2005. Funny. No?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)